Dominic Willmott, Siobhan Weare and Madeleine Millar on their ‘mock jury’ research and more.
12 November 2026
Sexual violence against men is more common than public conversation suggests. Globally, it is estimated that large numbers of men and boys will be subjected to an unwanted sexual experience in their lifetime (Boduszek et al., 2017; Willmott & Widanaralalage, 2024). In England and Wales, crime statistics for the year ending March 2025 report more than 162,000 men have been sexually victimised (Office for National Statistics, [ONS], 2025) and earlier crime figures indicate that one in 21 men report being raped or sexually assaulted since the age of 16 (ONS, 2020). A 2021 poll for the charity Mankind UK found even greater prevalence rates – one in seven UK men reported being coerced into sex, while one in ten reported having been raped or forced into non-consensual penetration (Savanta ComRes, 2021).
Even these figures likely understate the true scale of the problem. Four in five men who experience rape or assault by penetration do not report it to the police and more than a third believe what happened to them was wrong but not a crime (ONS, 2021). Barriers for reporting sexual violence are common for all victim groups, though research shows that they are especially challenging for male survivors given the added burden that gender role stereotypes play (Weare, 2017; Widanaralalage et al., 2025).
However, to be clear, this silence is not because the harm is less severe. Almost half of men report psychological or emotional challenges following their victimisation, around 40 per cent report physical injuries, and one in ten report attempting suicide (ONS, 2021). Academic research with male survivors is now growing at pace – so far, it indicates the harms emerging from male sexual victimisation are both substantial and multifaceted (Weare, 2021; Widanaralalage et al., 2022).
Why men stay silent
A major reason why men choose not to disclose their sexual victimisation is the persistence of what have become known as 'male rape myths'. Simply put, these are false or stereotyped beliefs that minimise, deny or ridicule men's experiences of sexual abuse. Some examples of these myths include that 'real men' are too strong to be raped, that male rape only affects gay men, and the idea that men raping other men generally only occurs inside prison (Willmott & Widanaralalage, 2024). These myths are often strongly tied to ideas about hegemonic masculinity where 'real' men are expected to be strong and capable of defending themselves, while victims are stereotyped as weak (Weare & Willmott, 2026). This is a contradiction that continues to fuel scepticism towards male survivors. Other common male rape myths concern the fallacy that many male victims are trying to hide their 'true' sexuality and have only alleged being a victim of male rape after being 'caught' having consensual sex with another man (Willmott & Widanaralalage, 2024). Other myths go as far as to suggest that men may have secretly sought out to become a victim in order to indulge in hidden fantasies emerging from their supposed 'true' sexuality.
Sadly, these beliefs remain widely held. In one US study, nearly a third of respondents agreed that a man's resistance determines whether he was raped and a similar proportion said they would not believe a man who told them he had been raped by a woman (Walfield, 2018). In Willmott and Widanaralalage's (2024) survey of 303 UK adults, men were found to endorse male rape myths significantly more than women, and respondents who were less empathetic towards victims of gendered crime were those who expressed the greatest belief in male rape myths overall.
There are tangible consequences to the endorsement of these myths. In particular, expressing a belief in rape myths may contribute to stigma which deters men from making informal disclosures (e.g. to friends or support organisations) or reporting formally to authorities such as the police. Morgan-Taylor and Rumney (2004) describe a case in which a trial judge directed a jury to acquit partly because the complainant reportedly had an erection during the assault; something that is itself a common male rape myth. In fact, only 90 defendants were found guilty among the roughly 9,000 men estimated to experience rape or attempted rape annually in the period examined, a conviction rate of around 1 per cent when set against estimated prevalence (see Millar et al., 2026). Whilst this overall conviction figure is similar to cases involving female rape complainants (Willmott et al., 2017), the underlying masculinity and sexuality biases are more unique to male victims.
What do we already know about jury decision-making in male rape trials?
Because juries decide guilt in rape trials, we wanted to know whether these male rape myths are likely to influence their decisions, in the same way that research has shown in female rape complainant cases (Willmott et al., 2026). As many jurisdictions do not permit research with real juries, researchers often rely upon mock jury studies to understand jury decision making. However, until recently, evidence on how jurors respond to male victims had been scattered and rarely consolidated. So, in our efforts to better understand what existing research shows, we systematically reviewed experimental studies published between 1980 and 2024, searching 11 databases (alongside additional sources) and identified 21 studies that met our pre-registered criteria (see Millar et al., 2026).
Interestingly, our systematic review findings were quite nuanced. About half of the studies found that the victim's gender made no difference to verdicts, and a smaller number found mock jurors were less punitive towards defendants when the victim was male. Only one study found the reverse, with higher guilt ratings but no difference in verdicts (Millar et al., 2026). Even where verdicts did not differ, several studies showed that mock jurors held harsher attitudes towards male victims, viewing them as less credible and more to blame, yet viewing defendants more favourably (Millar et al., 2026). Male jurors generally showed fewer pro-victim attitudes than female jurors, though this did not always translate into different verdict outcomes.
Victim characteristics also mattered. Mock jurors tended to be more lenient towards defendants and more critical of victims where the male victim was black, gay, or transgender (Millar et al., 2026). Unsurprisingly, higher juror scores in male rape myth acceptance were linked to lower perceived defendant guilt and these jurors were particularly unmoved by information designed to debunk male rape myths.
Our review also exposed serious gaps. None of the 21 studies allowed jurors to deliberate together before reaching a verdict, many used vignettes that did not reflect how male sexual violence typically occurs, and only a few measured male-specific rape myths (Millar et al., 2026). This is problematic if we are to extrapolate these findings to real male rape trial settings.
Our highly realistic mock trial
To address this, we ran the first study of its kind in England and Wales examining how juror characteristics relate to verdicts in a highly realistic male rape trial simulation (see Weare et al., 2025). Working with Avon and Somerset Constabulary, the Crown Prosecution Service, and We Are Survivors, we staged a series of highly realistic mock trials.
We employed the expertise of a genuine 'rape ticketed' Crown court judge, several experienced criminal barristers, and professional actors to play key roles in the trial, such as the defendant and complainant. We then re-enacted the trial live to our mock jurors using a case involving a male complainant and where the male defendant faced two counts of rape (one anal and one oral) under the Sexual Offences Act 2003. (It should be noted here that the current legal definition of rape only recognises men as principal offenders due to the requirement of penile penetration by the defendant of the complainant's vagina, anus, or mouth. Both men and women are recognised as victims under the 2003 Act.)
So, what did we find? Overall, across 12 separate mock jury panels, eight returned not guilty verdicts (four unanimous, four by majority), three were hung, and one returned a majority guilty decision. Surprisingly, three jury panels who viewed the same trial recreation all returned different verdicts; one guilty verdict, one not guilty verdict, and one hung jury. Male rape myths and stereotypes featured prominently in deliberations. Jurors drew on myths about the complainant's sexuality, about not 'fighting back', and about whether his allegations were truthful. Myths were evident across all jury panels, even in the deliberations of the jury panel who found the defendant guilty.
Jurors' prior attitudes and experiences mattered too. Those with higher pre-trial conviction proneness tendencies (assessed pre-trial) were significantly more likely to reach guilty verdicts on the anal rape count, both before and after deliberation. Interestingly, jurors who knew someone previously accused of a sexual offence rated the defendant's testimony as more believable overall and felt more confident in not-guilty verdict decisions that they selected (Weare et al., 2025). Many jurors also felt there was little evidence to consider, particularly without forensic evidence. Witness evidence, as well as live testimony from the complainant, were often not seen as 'real' evidence, largely because jurors were looking for DNA evidence or the figurative smoking gun that indicated guilt. Many jurors said they believed the complainant but did not feel sure enough of guilt to convict, struggling to reach the burden of proof.
Jury reform: What needs to change?
After conducting this highly realistic mock trial and based on careful consideration of our findings, including the jury deliberations themselves, we propose a number of recommendations for jury trial reform.
Firstly, it is clear that directions about myths and stereotypes must be case-specific rather than generic, taking account of the complainant's and defendant's gender and sexuality. It is not enough to simply apply myths and stereotype directions relevant to female complainant cases, in a rape trial with a male complainant (which often occurs).
Likewise, prosecutors and judges should now receive standalone training on male rape myths and male sexual victimisation, kept separate from general sexual offences training so the distinct nuances of men's experiences receive proper attention.
Prosecutors should also consider how best to present witness evidence so that jurors understand that testimony is real evidence, especially when forensic, CCTV, or phone evidence is limited or unavailable.
Finally, because real deliberations cannot be observed, policymakers should now prioritise realistic research methods, such as simulated trials. Greater access to real jury deliberations in a carefully controlled and limited way is essential if we are to understand whether our realistic mock trial findings from this study, translate (or not) to real jury trials. It is important to understand the challenges that male survivors specifically face; our research shows how myths that silence them before they reach a courtroom may also undermine them if and when their case reaches trial. Challenging those myths, in public settings and in the jury room, is essential if men who have been raped are to be heard and have the opportunity to seek justice at trial.
Where next for this research?
Whilst working on the publications emerging from the above studies, we have begun analysis for our next stream of mock jury research; examining whether similar biases impact decision making in female-on-male sexual assault trials. Here, we are exploring for the first time, what juries make of so called 'forced-to-penetrate' cases, where men allege being compelled to penetrate a woman without their consent. Recent research suggests widespread myths also surround these case types, including that men are not negatively affected by such non-consensual penetration and likely enjoy it (Massey et al., 2026), and that it is impossible for women to force men to have 'unwanted sex' given differences in physicality and strength alongside the belief that an erection signifies consent (see Weare & Willmott, 2025). In this mock trial research, we test for the first time whether such beliefs also influence juror judgements and decision making in female-on-male cases. More to come on this when our analysis is complete.
Dr Dominic Willmott is a Reader (Associate Professor) in Legal & Criminological Psychology at Loughborough University where he is responsible for the MSc Criminology programme. His research examines bias within criminal legal systems, investigating the existence and impact of rape myths upon jury decision-making. He is a Chartered Psychologist and Associate Fellow of the British Psychological Society.
Dr Siobhan Weare is a Reader in Law at Lancaster University. Her research expertise centres around criminal justice and socio-legal responses to sexual offences, particularly involving male sexual victimisation.
Dr Madeleine Millar is an Assistant Professor in Psychology and Law at Warwick University. Her research focuses on understanding how jurors make decisions, and biases in cognition which may undermine decision-making.
References
Boduszek, D., Debowska, A., Trotman Jemmott, E., Da Breo, H., Willmott, D., Sherretts, N., & Jones, A. D. (2017). Victimisation, violence perpetration, and attitudes towards violence among boys and girls from Barbados and Grenada. Huddersfield, UK: University of Huddersfield Press. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.12891.87848 (ISBN: 978-1-86218-148-9).
Massey, L., Parton, L. & Willmott, D. (2026). "I call bullshit - his Mrs probably found out he cheated and this was his way out of it": A Thematic Analysis of Public Attitudes towards Male Forced-to-Penetrate Victims. Behavioral Sciences, 16(11), 2024.
Millar, M., Weare, S., & Willmott, D. (2026). Mock jurors' determinations of guilt in sexual offences involving male victims: A systematic review. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 27(4), 2010–2025. https://doi.org/10.1177/15248380251366264
Morgan-Taylor, M., & Rumney, P. (2004). Making sense of sexual consent. In M. Cowling & P. Reynolds (Eds.), The construction of consent in cases of male rape and sexual assault (pp. 141–169). Ashgate.
Office for National Statistics. (2020). Sexual offences prevalence and victim characteristics, England and Wales [Data set]. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/datasets/sexualoffencesprevalenceandvictimcharacteristicsenglandandwales
Office for National Statistics. (2025). Sexual offences in England and Wales overview: Year ending March 2025. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/sexualoffencesinenglandandwalesoverview/yearendingmarch2025
Savanta ComRes. (2021). Mankind UK: Sexual consent poll [Data set]. https://savanta.com/knowledge-centre/poll/mankind-sexual-consent-poll-february-2021/
Weare, S. (2018). 'Oh you're a guy, how could you be raped by a woman, that makes no sense': towards a case for legally recognising and labelling 'forced-to-penetrate' cases as rape. International Journal of Law in Context, 14(1), 110-131.
Weare, S. (2021). "I feel permanently traumatized by it": Physical and emotional impacts reported by men forced to penetrate women in the United Kingdom. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 36(13-14), 6621-6646.
Weare, S. & Willmott, D. (2025). The Forced-to-Penetrate Myth Acceptance Scale (FTP-MAS): A new attitudinal tool for assessing myths that surround female perpetrated sexual violence against men. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 43, 158-168.
Weare, S., & Willmott, D. (2026). Validating the Male Rape Myth Scale–shortened version (MRMS-SV): Examining Melanson's original factorial structure among a large nationally representative sample of the UK. The Journal of Men's Studies, 34(1), 29-44.
Weare, S., Willmott, D. & Millar, M. (2025). Jury Decision Making in Male Rape Trials. Policy Brief: Lancaster University Press. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.10124.78724
Widanaralalage, B. K., Hine, B. A., Murphy, A. D., & Murji, K. (2022). "I didn't feel I was a victim": A phenomenological analysis of the experiences of male-on-male survivors of rape and sexual abuse. Victims & Offenders, 17(8), 1147-1172.
Widanaralalage, B. K., Jennings, S., Dando, C. J., & Mackenzie, J. M. (2025). 'We don't talk about that around here': an interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) of South Asian male survivors' experiences of childhood sexual abuse in the UK. BMC psychology, 13(1), 910.
Willmott, D., Boduszek, D. & Booth, N. (2017). The English Jury on Trial. The Custodial Review, 82, 12-14.
Willmott, D., Boduszek, D. & Booth, N. (2026). Profiling Jury Bias in Rape Trials: Examining the link between Juror Characteristics and Trial Decisions. In E. Dowds, S. Leahy & S. Weare (Eds.). Researching Rape Trials: Methods, Ethics and Empirical Perspectives (pp. 127-144). Routledge. DOI: 10.4324/9781003613015-10
Willmott, D., & Widanaralalage, B. K. (2024). Male rape myths: Examining the role of victim empathy and socio-demographics in a cross-sectional sample of UK adults. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice, 76, Article 100645. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlcj.2023.100645
SOURCE:
https://www.bps.org.uk/psychologist/how-jury-bias-impacting-justice-male-rape-victims(accessed 13.11.26)


